College Media Network - Search the largest news resource for college students by college students

Because I Got High: The facts and logical fallacies about marijuana use

By Opinion Staff

Print this article

Published: Sunday, April 19, 2009

Updated: Monday, April 20, 2009

Pot

Gumbo courtesy art

THE FACTS

No one has ever overdosed on marijuana
In 2001, 331 people died from alcohol overdose, with 75,000 people having alcohol-related deaths, according to the Center for Disease Control and Prevention. It is impossible to know the number of deaths caused by marijuana, although most experts agree it is significantly lower than alcohol.
 
Students lose federal aid when convicted for possessing marijuana
In 1998, an amendment to the Higher Education Act withdrew financial aid from students convicted of any drug offense — including simple possession — before or during studies. Although the bill has been scaled back to include only those convicted while in school, a bill introduced by Sen. Chris Dodd, D-Conn., seeks to repeal all penalties. More than 200,000 students have been denied aid by this provision, according to Students for Sensible Drug Policy.
 
Marijuana does not cause cancer
According to a UCLA study — the largest of its kind — even heavy marijuana use does not lead to lung cancer. Although marijuana contains known carcinogens, it is believed THC keeps cells from becoming cancerous. Marijuana     contains tar and other chemicals, which may lead to an elevated chance of bronchitis and respiratory infections. However, these risks can be nearly entirely eliminated by using a vaporizor — a device used as an alternative to smoking — which only combusts the THC.
 
Marijuana is not addictive
While any behavior can become a force of habit, marijuana is not physically addictive. Those who experience withdrawl symptoms, if experienced at all, are extremely mild. Nicotine withdrawl is much worse by comparison.
 
Marijuana has not been proven to impair long term brain function
While intoxication impairs learning ability and memory, no study has proven any long-term cognitive effects of marijuana. There is no evidence that marijuana kills brain cells.
 
Marijuana is America’s No. 1 cash crop
Although the exact amount is impossible to know, one study estimated the total marijuana production in the U.S. in 2006 to be $35.8 billion. That’s more than the combined value of domestic corn ($23.3 billion) and wheat ($7.5 billion).
 
Marijuana has medicinal value
Marijuana is useful in reducing nausea in chemotherapy patients, reducing the pressure of glaucoma and stimulating appetite for AIDs patients, aside from other treatments for pain. Critics argue the commercially produced pill Marinol is not as effective as smoking marijuana.
 
Legalizing marijuana would have a net benefit of about $15 billion per year
If marijuana was taxed like tobacco and alcohol it could bring in $6.2 billion, according to a 2005 Harvard study. The nation would save $7.7 billion in law enforcement ($5.3 billion in state and local government expenses, $2.4 billion in federal expenses). Who knows how much of the federal deficit could be eliminated by taxing marijuana consumption.
 
THE LOGICAL FALLACIES


The gateway theory
Correlation does not prove causation. Simlarly, as Austin, Texas criminal defense lawyer Jamie Spencer put it, lack of correlation does show lack of causation. On Spencer’s Web site, a Dallas lawyer explained why ineffective government programs like the DARE program don’t reduce drug use.

Legalizing marijuana is not a good investment for “the children”
Legalizing and regulating marijuana might make it more difficult for young people to get their hands on it. But do we have a problem with anyone under 15 abusing alcohol today? Why would it make a difference?
 
Marijuana causes people to be unmotivated
Coed Magazine created a list of the ten most successful pot-smokers of all time.
The list included Sir Richard Branson, Michael Phelps, Michael Bloomberg, Ted Turner, Stephen King and California Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger.

Compiled and written by Mark Macmurdo.




——
Contact The Daily Reveille's opinion staff at opinion@lsureveille.com

Comments

19 comments
Ryan E Davis ippy
Thu Jun 18 2009 10:17
i like weed! i spend all of my money on it... im homeless but i don't care because i am sooo high all of the time... its actually exelerating but i love living in the local library front door.
OG
Fri Jun 12 2009 13:27
There used to be an active NORML chapter at LSU, you guys must have gotten high. . .
john doe
Mon Jun 1 2009 13:52
That list of famous pot smokers couldn't be complete without Carl Sagan.
Legalize It
Thu May 28 2009 14:18
Has anyone ever heard of a parent coming home stoned and abusing their kids? I know I have heard of parents coming home drunk and abusing them. It just makes more since to legalize it.
Tay
Sun May 24 2009 00:09
Can we add Obama to the successful list, especially if he actually starts the legalization process!!
sw
Fri May 22 2009 15:06
As much as I'd love to see legalization happen I don't see it happening. Not with the influence alcohol and tobacco corporations have.
Kelsey
Thu May 21 2009 01:36
Weed doesn't kill people... btw. There have never been any reported deaths of just marijuana alone. People are dumb if they think weed kills people.

As the late, great Bill Hicks preaches: Weed shouldn't just be legalized, it should be MANDATORY.

Phil E. Drifter
Wed May 20 2009 13:53
"While intoxication impairs learning ability and memory, no study has proven any long-term cognitive effects of marijuana. There is no evidence that marijuana kills brain cells."

On the contrary, it is unique among drugs because it actually causes your hippocampus to produce new neurons; that is, new brain cells.

Your name
Thu Apr 23 2009 19:49
$Trillion spent is a $Trillion earned...
Cannabis prohibition has cost tax payers $1 Trillion since 1937. Some body got the money. They don't want to give it up. Nothing to do with kids or dangers of pot. Nixon lumped Hemp and Medicinal into the mix rejecting his own scientific study. Starting the CSA and the modern drug war. Nothing to do with kids or the dangers of pot. Coincidentally removing hemp fiber steel, wood, plastic, cotton, polyfiber and protein competition.

While keeping the booze and drug stores free of competition, and 90 million pounds of abortion causing chemicals on US cotton, not required for hemp. Simultaneously continuing to collect another $Trillion from the workers "saved da kids".

Tell Your Children
Tue Apr 21 2009 12:31
Mark said, "I am all for legalizing weed. but are you really gonna say weed doesn't make you unmotivated...please. "

Why, yes, Mark. Vaporizing this amazing plant removes the part responsible for the pot stupor and lethargy. It's amazing. I can get stoned and still out "Jeopardy" anyone I know. No more, "Dude...like, dude, wow.."... no more Jeff Spicoli!

Mark said, "maybe they should smoke some weed, might help them understand the complex math problems".

And speaking of complex math problems...I have an engineering degree with a minor in physics! I can run rings of numbers around most people.

The days of Reefer Madness are quickly coming to a close! Throw away your bias....it looks bad.

Legalize, Regulate, and Tax

Hector
Tue Apr 21 2009 12:03
Weed doesn't make you unmotivated... I smoke weed about five times a week for the last three or four years, have a part-time job and I'm a full-time student graduating in a week and a half. If you're lazy you can smoke or drink and use it as an excuse, but plenty of productive people smoke pot. If you're unmotivated, you're unmotivated, pot is not gonna change that.
don
Tue Apr 21 2009 11:38
mark, maybe you are just lazy regardless of weed.

If someone is unmotivated, cannabis will probably not motivate them.
If you ARE a motivated person, cannabis can be a help depending on the tasks at hand.

Your name
Tue Apr 21 2009 10:38
Yo Mark,
weed does not make you unmotivated unless you are unmotivated to begin with. The truth is,if anything it makes you more contemplative and open to new ideologies that are counter to the ones that have been ingrained in your head through generations of refer madness. One could hardly say that Michael Phelps, Robert Mitchum, Carl Sagan, Drew Carey, even one of the worlds most famous pot smoker "Snoop Dog" is a very highly motivated individual, the list goes on of extremely motivated pot smokers. This is just more of the B.S. beliefs that surround the marijuana issue.
Dover
Tue Apr 21 2009 03:35
@Mark

I am a 50 year old scientist and smoke weed every day, want to compete with me on complex math problems?

Jackson
Tue Apr 21 2009 02:56
I'm a considerably successful businessman, mark, and nobody in their right mind could consider me for a second 'unmotivated' when high. In fact, quite the opposite.
mark
Mon Apr 20 2009 13:29
I am all for legalizing weed. but are you really gonna say weed doesn't make you unmotivated...please.
mark
Mon Apr 20 2009 12:51
maybe they should smoke some weed, might help them understand the complex math problems.
Luke
Mon Apr 20 2009 08:49
Most experts do agree that 0 is significantly lower than 75,000. I think it is mainly politicians, law enforcement and rehab centers who find this complex math problem difficult.
Nick
Mon Apr 20 2009 01:09
If only the stubborn Government could see whats Good haha